HEBER, Imperial County — November 12, 2026. A legal opinion issued by California's attorney general on November 6 could put the composition of two local public boards before a court. In Opinion 26-902, Attorney General Rob Bonta granted Diahna Garcia-Ruiz permission to bring a quo warranto lawsuit challenging Helen Diaz Molina and Tony Sandoval, who simultaneously serve as directors of the Heber Public Utility District and trustees of the Heber Elementary School District. The attorney general concluded that the compatibility of the offices raises a substantial question for a judge. This is permission to file a lawsuit, not a determination that either official illegally holds office.
Why the two jobs could conflict
Heber's utility district supplies drinking water, treats sewage and provides garbage services to a community of about 7,300 residents, according to the six-page published opinion. The elementary district oversees two schools serving approximately 1,100 students. Both organizations have five-member boards. In their school-board capacity, trustees have incentives and duties connected with controlling district costs; as utility directors, they may have responsibilities to maintain service revenues and set rates. The utility district services the school district, creating a possible clash of loyalties even without a documented improper vote.
What the applicant argues
Garcia-Ruiz contends that simultaneously serving on the two boards violates California Government Code § 1099, which restricts incompatible public offices. She asks permission to seek removal from whichever office each defendant held first, as the statute may require after a court determines incompatibility. The parties disagree in part about the order in which the posts were assumed. The AG opinion describes the dispute but does not adjudicate the facts or issue an order removing either person.
How the officials responded
The attorney general's published text says the proposed defendants opposed the application. Diaz Molina argued, among other points, that the dispute was politically motivated and permitting litigation would not serve the public interest. Sandoval argued the issue could become moot when his utility-board term ends in December 2026, and questioned whether the claim properly identified which office he held first. The AG concluded that the public interest in a judicial decision and potential conflicts outweighed those objections. The opinion does not establish that either person acted corruptly or misused funds.
Why residents should care
Utility-board directors are responsible for vital services and water costs; school trustees are responsible for budgets and educational oversight. One individual participating in decisions on both sides of a water-rate or services relationship could create a governance dilemma. The final ruling, if a lawsuit proceeds, should be based on the actual duties, records and legal standards, not on assumptions about personal character or political allegiance.
HEBER NEWS UPDATE — November 12, 2026: Our local newsroom has sent an on-the-record request to the Heber Public Utility District, copying directors Tony Sandoval and Helen Diaz Molina and the Heber Elementary School District's superintendent's office. The request seeks public board documents, current officeholder status and responses to the issues raised by Attorney General Opinion 26-902. No new reply has yet been received. The AG's approval to sue is not an office-removal order.
Questions Heber News will pursue
- Has a quo warranto complaint actually been filed following the November 6 authorization, and in which court?
- Which meetings or decisions involve contracts, rates or other transactions between the school and utility districts?
- Have board members made public disclosures or recused themselves from any overlapping decisions?
- Who would fill a vacancy if a court determines a board position was forfeited?
- Can both districts publish relevant service contracts, board agendas, minutes and written legal responses in accessible form?
Primary sources: California Attorney General's official Opinion 26-902 (November 6, 2026) and the official opinions index. The legal opinion itself provides the key facts, the two officials' objections and the AG's reasoning. No source-verified YouTube recording of the decision was found, so Heber News is linking to the authentic public record rather than assigning an unrelated video cover. Residents and board representatives may submit public documents and attributed corrections to Heber News.
Support Heber News
Choose how to support Heber News:
Credit / Debit Card via StripeChoose your contribution amount on the secure California58 Stripe checkout. One-time support for independent local journalism.
Continue with PayPal Continue with ZelleZelle payments go to Vitaly Ataev Troshin. Please verify the recipient in your bank before sending. Availability depends on your bank.
Optional reader support. When possible, add “Heber News” to the payment note. Contributions are not advertised as tax-deductible. Support does not influence editorial decisions.More from Heber News
- Heber Public Utility District Services: Water, Wastewater, Waste Collection and Recreation →
- Heber Utility Board Meetings: When to Attend, How to Comment and Where to Find Agendas →
- Heber's Community Advisory Committee: How Residents Can Follow Imperial County Decisions →
- Heber Water and Sewer Rates: Where Residents Can Read the 2026 Utility Board Records →
COMMUNITY
Comments
Join the California58 conversation. You must be signed in to comment.
Create a free California58 account or sign in with an available social provider.